Finding the perfect eye serum can be a game-changer for under-eye concerns like fine lines, puffiness, or dullness.

After testing a few, here’s how each one performed for me—based on feel, effect, packaging, and price!

1. Dior Capture Totale Super Potent Eye Serum – 9/10

This serum delivers impressive results, especially for softening fine lines under the eyes. While it comes with a higher price tag, the product lasts much longer than expected. The cooling applicator is a standout—it feels soothing and makes application feel like a mini eye massage.

2. Drunk-Elephant Shaba Complex Eye Serum – 5/10

Although the reformulated version now includes retinol and a new look, it didn’t work as well for me. My eyes felt a bit dry shortly after applying it. The packaging is cute, but without a cooling applicator or noticeable results, it’s not one I’d reach for again.

3. Charlotte Tilbury Cryo-Recovery Eye Serum – 7/10

This one’s a mixed bag. It brightened and smoothed my under-eyes nicely, and the applicator is beautiful and refreshing to use. However, for the price, I hoped for more anti-aging results like what I experienced with Dior’s serum.

Whether you're after hydration, anti-aging, or a brightening boost, these eye serums offer different strengths. Hope this roundup helps if you're narrowing down your next pick!